Penelope Rio represents Penelope’s experimental approach to blending, combining their signature four-grain bourbon with additional finishing techniques. Priced around $79-$89, this bottle aims to offer something different in the crowded bourbon landscape, but the execution leaves room for improvement.
Quick Take
| Profile: Cinnamon-forward with honey sweetness and medicinal undertones |
| Complexity: Shows interesting layers but lacks cohesion between elements |
| Standout Feature: Bold cinnamon spice throughout the experience |
| Best For: Adventurous drinkers curious about experimental blends |
| Watch Out: Medicinal notes and short finish may disappoint traditional bourbon fans |
The Penelope Story
Penelope Bourbon was founded by Mike Paladini and Danny Polise in 2018, with the brand named after Paladini’s daughter, Penelope. While Bardstown Bourbon Company acquired the brand in 2023, the Rio expression remains a hallmark of Penelope’s innovative Cooper Series. This limited release uses their signature four-grain mash bill and features a double-finish in American Oak barrels and Brazilian Amburana casks. It is a bold experiment in flavor, though the heavy influence of the Amburana spice makes it a polarizing “work in progress” for some traditionalists.
Production and Specifications
Penelope Rio utilizes its signature four-grain mash bill (76% Corn, 14% Wheat, 7% Rye, 3% Malted Barley). Part of the Cooper Series, this expression undergoes a unique double-finish process: it is first aged in American Oak Honey Barrels before being moved to Brazilian Amburana casks. This combination is designed to marry the floral sweetness of honey with the intense, savory spice of the Amburana wood.
Appearance
In the glass, Penelope Rio presents a medium amber color with copper highlights. The liquid moves with moderate viscosity, suggesting a decent body without being particularly rich or oily. It’s an attractive pour that sets reasonable expectations for what’s to come.
Nose
The aroma opens with prominent cinnamon spice, immediately announcing itself as a spice-forward bourbon. Behind the cinnamon, subtle floral notes emerge, likely from the wheat in the mash bill. The nose is pleasant if somewhat one-dimensional, with the cinnamon dominating most other characteristics. There’s a slight alcohol bite that suggests this isn’t the most refined expression in terms of integration.
Palate
The first sip delivers on the cinnamon promise from the nose, with warm baking spice leading the charge. Oak tannins provide structure, while honey sweetness attempts to balance the spice. However, medicinal notes intrude on the experience, creating an almost antiseptic quality that disrupts the flow. Orange citrus tries to brighten things up but gets overshadowed by the competing elements. The four-grain complexity is there, but it feels more chaotic than harmonious.
Finish
Unfortunately, the finish is where Penelope Rio really struggles. It’s notably short, which is disappointing for a bourbon at this price point. The cinnamon, oak, and honey linger briefly before fading quickly, leaving you wanting more substance. The medicinal notes from the palate don’t help matters, creating an almost clinical aftertaste that doesn’t invite another sip.
Who Should Buy This
Penelope Rio might appeal to bourbon drinkers who enjoy heavily spiced expressions and don’t mind experimental approaches to traditional whiskey making. If you’re drawn to cinnamon-forward spirits or curious about four-grain mash bills, this could be worth trying. However, traditionalists looking for classic bourbon characteristics should probably look elsewhere.
Where to Buy
Penelope Rio typically retails for $79-$89 and can be found at many specialty liquor stores and online retailers. Availability varies by region, but it’s becoming more widely distributed as Penelope expands its reach. Check with local whiskey shops or search online retailers like Total Wine, Binny’s, or the the brand’s website for current availability in your area.
FAQ
What is a four-grain bourbon?
Four-grain bourbon uses corn, wheat, rye, and malted barley in its mash bill, compared to traditional three-grain recipes. This approach aims to create more complex flavor profiles by incorporating characteristics from each grain type.
How much does Penelope Rio cost?
Penelope Rio typically retails for $79-$89 positioning it in the premium bourbon category alongside other craft distillery offerings.
Is Penelope Rio good for bourbon beginners?
Not particularly. The medicinal notes and experimental nature make it better suited for experienced bourbon drinkers who enjoy trying unique expressions.
What foods pair well with spice-forward bourbon?
Cinnamon-heavy bourbons like Penelope Rio pair well with desserts like apple pie, dark chocolate, or even spicy barbecue dishes that can complement the spice profile.
Where can I buy Penelope Rio?
Look for it at specialty liquor stores, larger chains like Total Wine, or online retailers. Availability is growing as the company expands distribution.
Final Verdict
Penelope Rio earns 2.5 out of 5 stars as an interesting but ultimately flawed experiment. While I appreciate Penelope’s willingness to innovate with their four-grain approach, this particular expression feels unfinished. The cinnamon spice shows promise, and the honey sweetness provides nice moments, but the medicinal notes and disappointingly short finish prevent it from being a recommendation. At $79-$89, there are simply better options available that deliver more balanced and satisfying experiences. It’s not a terrible bourbon, but it’s not a particularly good one either.
