—Neat or Not Reviews

All Whiskey Reviews

Bourbon, rye, and American whiskeys reviewed and ranked — searchable by style, price, and score.

Filter Reviews
Minglewood Bourbon
Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Ohio

Minglewood Straight Bourbon

A pepper-forward sip sparked by a Rackhouse Tavern nudge in Lexington, KY

FULL REVIEW →

88 Proof
Age: At least 4 years
Everyday Sipper
Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Pennsylvania

White-Tail Pennsylvania Straight Bourbon

A 90-proof Pennsylvania sweetheart with a long tobacco goodbye

FULL REVIEW →

90 Proof
Age: at least 2 years
Outstanding
Old Elk Wheated Straight Bourbon
Wheated
Colorado

Old Elk Straight Bourbon - Wheated

A light, fruit-forward pour that’s approachable and smooth, but stops short of memorable.

FULL REVIEW →

92 Proof
Age: At least 4 years
Everyday Sipper
Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Pennsylvania

Wigle Reserve

Leather first, questions later

FULL REVIEW →

92 Proof
Age: 4 Years
Excellent
Cask Strength, Single Barrel, Straight Bourbon Whiskey
North Carolina

Conviction Founders Reserve

A cask strength sour mash from Southern Grace Distilling, uncut, unfiltered, and aged in a prison grain bin

FULL REVIEW →

118.4 Proof
Age: At least 4 years
Excellent
Conviction Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Cask Strength, Single Barrel, Straight Bourbon Whiskey
North Carolina

Conviction Straight Bourbon Whiskey

A Charlotte detour, a grain-to-glass surprise, and a bottle I’ll happily buy again

FULL REVIEW →

104 Proof
Age: 7 years
Outstanding